True crime has always hooked us with its chilling twists and real-life horrors, but nothing grips like watching those dark tales unfold on screen. From courtroom dramas to psychological thrillers, TV adaptations bring these stories to life in ways that keep us glued—yet not every retelling earns praise. Dive in as we rank 25 must-watch true crime shows based on their Tomatometer scores, revealing why some become instant classics while others spark heated debates. And trust me, this list might just change how you view justice on TV!
Tagged as: binge (https://editorial.rottentomatoes.com/tag/binge/), Binge Guide (https://editorial.rottentomatoes.com/tag/binge-guide/), streaming (https://editorial.rottentomatoes.com/tag/streaming/), TV (https://editorial.rottentomatoes.com/tag/tv/)
The newest addition: Murdaugh: Death in the Family (https://www.rottentomatoes.com/tv/murdaughdeathinthefamily) is now available for streaming on Hulu.
Television has become the go-to medium for true crime adaptations, turning actual events into gripping narratives that unfold in your living room. Think of it as a bridge between reality and fiction, where we relive the most shocking cases through expertly crafted stories. Iconic anthologies like American Crime Story (https://www.rottentomatoes.com/tv/americancrimestory) stand out, alongside powerful limited series such as Unbelievable (https://www.rottentomatoes.com/tv/unbelievable), Dopesick (https://www.rottentomatoes.com/tv/dopesick), and When They See Us (https://www.rottentomatoes.com/tv/whentheysee_us). These productions offer emotional depth and raw honesty, reimagining tragedies that linger in our collective memory. For beginners in true crime, these shows often simplify complex legal processes, like how evidence is gathered or trials unfold, making the genre accessible without overwhelming newcomers.
What follows is a curated list of 25 true crime adaptations ranked by their Tomatometer scores—perfect for building your binge-watching queue. To make the cut, each series needed at least 10 critic reviews. We've prioritized Certified Fresh titles at the top, so you can spot the critical darlings first.
1
Critics Consensus: With its heartbreaking intensity and undeniable power, Unbelievable breaks free from typical true-crime formulas by focusing compassionately on abuse survivors, narrating their journeys with elegance and solemnity. This approach not only educates viewers on the aftermath of trauma but also sparks conversations about empathy in storytelling.
2
Critics Consensus: Dennis Lehane's knack for gritty realism shines through in Blackbird, a riveting prison drama that dives into moral gray areas with a standout cast that elevates every scene. For those new to the genre, it highlights how incarceration affects human ethics, offering a deeper look at rehabilitation versus punishment.
3
Critics Consensus: American Crime Story: The People v. O.J. Simpson masterfully blends exceptional writing, directing, and performances to tackle a timeless controversy, illuminating hidden facts and stirring strong emotions. But here's where it gets controversial—does reviving such a polarizing case risk sensationalizing real pain?
4
Critics Consensus: Ava DuVernay delivers a unflinching portrayal in When They See Us, chronicling the Central Park Five's ordeal with added layers of humanity that prompt us to rethink American justice. It's a reminder, especially for beginners, that wrongful convictions can stem from systemic biases, encouraging viewers to question eyewitness reliability.
5
Critics Consensus: While The Staircase may not surprise fans of the original documentary, its scripted version adds vivid details and a stellar Colin Firth performance that breathes new life into the enigma. This adaptation shows how TV can humanize suspects, blurring lines between guilt and innocence.
6
Critics Consensus: A Friend of the Family unfolds like a creeping dread, bolstered by Eliza Hittman's skilled guidance and Jake Lacy's raw depiction of subtle menace. And this is the part most people miss—how it subtly critiques family dynamics in hiding abuse, a theme that resonates in many real-life scandals.
7
Critics Consensus: Anchored by Elle Fanning's haunting turn, The Girl from Plainville handles a grim tale with tasteful nuance, avoiding cheap shocks. For newcomers, it illustrates the opioid crisis's personal toll, expanding on how addiction destroys communities.
8
Critics Consensus: As a docudrama, The Dropout shines brighter than as dark humor, with Amanda Seyfried's unsettling take on Elizabeth Holmes injecting vitality into a modern cautionary tale. But here's where it gets controversial—is portraying innovators as villains fair, or does it oversimplify ambition?
9
Critics Consensus: Dopesick sometimes struggles under its heavy themes, yet Michael Keaton and Kaitlyn Dever's compelling work, paired with a sympathetic lens on opioid victims, creates profoundly moving drama. This series educates on public health crises, showing how corporate greed fuels epidemics.
10
Critics Consensus: Patricia Arquette and Joey King's layered portrayals in The Act make a solid argument for why true crime dramas endure, blending suspense with psychological insight.
11
Critics Consensus: The Assassination of Versace kicks off explosively and weaves a complex web of clues, buoyed by Darren Criss's transformative role in this backward-unfolding mystery.
12
Critics Consensus: Sofía Vergara vanishes into Griselda Blanco's world in this fast-paced cartel chronicle, which takes liberties with history for authentic edge. And this is the part most people miss—does romanticizing criminals perpetuate harmful stereotypes?
13
Critics Consensus: Under the Bridge tenderly dissects a savage puzzle, sometimes skipping key details but succeeding as a study in adolescent brutality.
14
Critics Consensus: With its inherently thrilling plot needing minimal drama, Welcome to Chippendales flamboyantly recounts a male empire's feud through stylish storytelling.
15
Synopsis: "American Sports Story" is a scripted anthological limited series that focuses on a prominent event involving a sports figure and More. Imagine blending athletic glory with scandal—it's a fresh twist on how fame can mask dark secrets, perfect for fans of crossover genres.
16
Synopsis: "American Sports Story" is a scripted anthological limited series that focuses on a prominent event involving a sports figure and More. (Note: This appears to be a duplicate entry in the original; we've preserved it as is for accuracy.)
17
Synopsis: Maggie and Alex enjoy a lavish life of privilege as members of one of South Carolina's most powerful legal dynasties; More. This family saga exposes how wealth and influence can shield—or unravel—those in high places.
18
Synopsis: Candy Montgomery is a 1980's housewife and mother who did everything right: a good husband, two kids, even the careful More. Her story challenges suburban ideals, revealing hidden turmoil beneath perfect facades.
19
Synopsis: An American college student named Amanda goes to Italy for a study abroad program, but is wrongfully imprisoned for murder; More. It delves into justice abroad, highlighting cultural clashes in legal systems.
20
Critics Consensus: Impeachment wavers between exposing a scandal's human side and embracing its media frenzy, though Beanie Feldstein and Sarah Paulson's authentic chemistry cuts through the chaos. But here's where it gets controversial—does dramatizing political sex scandals trivialize serious misconduct?
21
Synopsis: A journalist investigates the case of Anna Delvey, the Instagram-legendary heiress who stole the hearts and money of New York More. Think social media scams turned epic con—it's a modern fable of deception.
22
Critics Consensus: Elizabeth Olsen breathes energy into Love & Death, yet this standard murder recap fails to stand out in the crowded true crime field.
23
Critics Consensus: Monster tries to critique glorifying Jeffrey Dahmer but Ryan Murphy's indulgent style veers into unsettling sensationalism. And this is the part most people miss—is it ethical to humanize monsters at the risk of sympathy?
24
Critics Consensus: Solid acting in Monsters turns a tawdry tale into something guilt-inducing without redeeming value.
25
Critics Consensus: Well-acted but off-puttingly sordid, Monsters leaves viewers feeling guilty without enough pleasure to compensate. (Note: Another apparent duplicate; preserved for fidelity.)
What do you think? Are these rankings spot-on, or have we missed a favorite? Do you believe some true crime shows exploit victims for thrills? Share your thoughts in the comments—let's debate the line between education and exploitation!
Enjoyed this? Sign up for our newsletter to receive weekly features, updates, and binge guides straight to your inbox. (https://www.rottentomatoes.com/newsletter)
Using an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News (https://apple.news/Tey6JRlfvQ4mnS2lJ9pyV7w?subscribe=1).
