Here’s a bombshell for streaming fans: YouTube TV may have just handed Disney a major victory in their recent deal—and it’s all about the money. But here’s where it gets controversial: Did YouTube TV cave on pricing, and will subscribers end up footing the bill? Let’s dive in.
The dust has finally settled on the YouTube TV and Disney agreement, with channels back on the platform and services like Movies Anywhere returning to normal. Yet, as more details emerge, it’s clear YouTube TV made some significant concessions, particularly on pricing. A recent CNBC newsletter by reporter Alexander Sherman sheds light on the finer points of the deal, and they’re worth unpacking.
And this is the part most people miss: YouTube TV reportedly aimed to structure the deal around its projected growth, anticipating it would soon become the largest distributor in the U.S. Earlier reports hinted that Google sought a 1-year agreement with this in mind, even discussing a “sliding scale” where Disney channel fees would adjust if YouTube TV’s subscriber base surged during the multiyear contract. Spoiler alert: That didn’t happen. Instead, YouTube TV will pay standard rates based on its current size, not its future potential. Ouch.
But that’s not all. Disney also managed to sneak in a per-subscriber fee for ESPN Unlimited content on YouTube TV. The exact cost remains a mystery, leaving us wondering: Will this hike YouTube TV’s expenses, and if so, will subscribers see a price increase? It’s a question that’s hard to ignore.
Interestingly, the timing of this deal may have spared Disney an awkward situation. With NBC’s contract with Fubo (now majority-owned by Disney) nearing expiration, Disney could have found itself negotiating on both sides if the YouTube TV dispute had dragged on. Crisis averted, it seems.
Now, here’s the real question: Did YouTube TV give away too much, or is this just the cost of doing business with a media giant like Disney? Let’s not forget, YouTube TV is also rumored to launch a lower-cost sports bundle next year (minus MLB.TV) and has been offering select users $60 off their first month to return after the Disney fallout. Plus, there’s that $20 credit for lost Disney content—a small consolation, perhaps.
What do you think? Did YouTube TV make the right call, or did they let Disney call the shots? Share your thoughts in the comments below—this is one debate that’s far from over.
For more updates, follow Ben on Twitter/X, Threads, Bluesky, and Instagram. And remember, we use income-earning auto affiliate links to keep the lights on. Stay tuned!
